I was looking for a shadow that was not toxic to use instead of the natural...

I was looking for a shadow that was not toxic to use instead of the natural mineral eye shadow I have been using. I was having to deal with a lot of flacking and find that by the end of a few hours I was wearing my shadow on my cheek bones and under my eyes, instead of on my eye lid. NOT a great look. So I use RMS tinted sunscreen and like that so I thought I would try this shadow quartet. So far, it stays put. However, I find it too shiny for me. I like a mat shadow and use primarily a dark brown or black. I am going to soldier on with this but really hope Ms. Rose-Marie will do a basic mat palette with this stay put power. Love the advertising. . . Did I just say that?!